Defenses: Difference between revisions

Help

Content added Content deleted

Inline

Latest revision as of 15:06, 18 September 2023

Overview

Summary article: Combat and defense

Related article: Combat

Related article: Beginner's Guide

There are multiple Resources, kinds of Buildings, and designs of Terrain that can serve as defense against attacking forces (be those animals or people).

Armor

Considered as either a Villager's first line (if they're out exploring) or last line (if they're inside the Settlement and all other defenses have been defeated) of defense are the clothes on their back. Here are how those options compare.

Item	Armor¹	Cost	Source	Notes
Linen Clothes	0	?	Trading Post, Weaver Building
Hide Coats	?	?	Tannery, Trading Post
Hauberks	?	?	Armory, Trading Post	Can only be worn by a Guard or Soldier.
Platemail Armor	?	?	Arsenal, Trading Post	Can only be worn by a Guard or Soldier.

¹ This is how much an attack's effect on the wearer is reduced.

Shield

This section pending.

Walls and fences

The game offers both fences and walls, both of which serve to keep invading forces at bay.

Building	Class	Tier	Armor	Health	Cost¹	Upgrades to
Fence	Roads and Fencing	1	0	50	2L 1W	N/A
Fence Gate	Roads and Fencing	1	0	40	15L 4W	N/A
Fieldstone Fence	Roads and Fencing	2	1	180	3L 1S	N/A
Hedge Fence	Roads and Fencing	3	0	100	3L 4C 15G	N/A
Hedge Fence Gate	Roads and Fencing	3	20²	1800²	50L 8W 15C 30G	N/A
Wrought Iron Fence	Roads and Fencing	4	2	200	3L 3i 2C 15G	N/A
Wrought Iron Fence Gate	Roads and Fencing	4	20²	1800²	50L 10i 15C 50G	N/A
Palisade Wall	Defenses	2	19	800	3L 3W	Fortified Wall
Palisade Gate	Defenses	2	15	650	15L 12W	Fortified Gate
Fortified Wall	Defenses	3	32	1500	10L 3S	N/A
Fortified Gate	Defenses	3	25	1200	50L 8W 10S	N/A

¹ Cost in Labor, Wood, Stone, iron, Clay, Gold
² These numbers seem suspiciously out of line with all the others. Crate Entertainment has been notified.

The issue of the outrageous armor & health values, for both the Hedge Fence Gate & Wrought Iron Fence Gate, was raised with Crate Entertainment as forum post #130368. (2023-09-10)

What is the labor cost to upgrade a palisade wall/gate to a fortified wall/gate?

When upgrading a Palisade Wall to a Fortified Wall the game only indicates that it will cost 3 Stone, and doesn't say anything about the labor cost.

If you instead Salvage Building, you will recover 2 Logs (which is the 50% of the original 3 logs investment rounded up) and could then build the fortified wall in its place. Is the benefit of upgrading that the wall is still "there" during the upgrade process, not leaving you vulnerable?

When upgrading a Palisade Gate to a Fortified Gate the game doesn't say anything about the labor cost, and indicates that it will cost 8 Logs & 10 Stone (even though you've already made a 12 log investment building the palisade gate).

Similar with the palisade gate. Salvaging recovers 6 Logs. It is unknown if upgrading recovers any of the originally invested resources.

@@ Line 3: / Line 3: @@
 == Overview ==
+: ''Summary article: [[Combat and defense]]''
-There are multiple kinds of [[Buildings]], structures, terrains (and designs leveraging some/all of these) that can serve as a defensive wall against attacking forces (be they animals or people).
+{{related|Combat}}
+{{related|Beginner's Guide}}
+<onlyinclude>There are multiple [[Resources]], kinds of [[Buildings]], and designs of [[Terrain]] that can serve as defense against attacking forces (be those animals or people).</onlyinclude>
-== Comparison of walls and fences ==
+== Armor ==
-The game offers walls ''and'' fences, both of which serve to keep invading forces at bay.
+Considered as either a [[Villager]]'s first line (if they're out exploring) or last line (if they're inside the Settlement and all other defenses have been defeated) of defense are the clothes on their back. Here are how those options compare.
+{| class="wikitable sortable"
+! Item !! Armor<sup>1</sup> !! Cost !! Source !! Notes
+|-
+| [[Linen Clothes]]
+| {{if2|{{Show|armor|Linen Clothes}}|<mark>0</mark>}}
+| {{if2|{{Show|cost|Linen Clothes}}|<mark>?</mark>}}
+| {{if2|{{Show|Produced by|Linen Clothes}}|<mark>[[Trading Post]], [[Weaver Building]]</mark>}}
+|
+|-
+| [[Hide Coats]]
+| {{if2|{{Show|armor|Hide Coats}}|<mark>?</mark>}}
+| {{if2|{{Show|cost|Hide Coats}}|<mark>?</mark>}}
+| {{if2|{{Show|Produced by|Hide Coats}}|<mark>[[Tannery]], [[Trading Post]]</mark>}}
+|
+|-
+| [[Hauberks]]
+| {{if2|{{Show|armor|Hauberks}}|<mark>?</mark>}}
+| {{if2|{{Show|cost|Hauberks}}|<mark>?</mark>}}
+| {{if2|{{Show|Produced by|Hauberks}}|<mark>[[Armory]], [[Trading Post]]</mark>}}
+| Can only be worn by a [[Guard]] or [[Soldier]].
+|-
+| [[Platemail Armor]]
+| {{if2|{{Show|armor|Platemail Armor}}|<mark>?</mark>}}
+| {{if2|{{Show|cost|Platemail Armor}}|<mark>?</mark>}}
+| {{if2|{{Show|Produced by|Platemail Armor}}|<mark>[[Arsenal]], [[Trading Post]]</mark>}}
+| Can only be worn by a [[Guard]] or [[Soldier]].
+|}
+<sup>1</sup> This is how much an attack's effect on the wearer is reduced.
+== Shield ==
+<mark>This section pending.</mark>
+== Walls and fences ==
+The game offers both [[:Category|fences and walls]], both of which serve to keep invading forces at bay.
 {|| class="wikitable sortable"
-! Building                    !! Class                 !! Tier !! Armor !! Health !! Cost<sup>1</sup>
+! Building                    !! Class                 !! Tier !! Armor !! Health !! Cost<sup>1</sup> !! Upgrades to
 |-
-| [[Fence]]                   || [[Roads and Fencing]] || 1 || 0 || 50 || 2L 1W
+| [[Fence]]                   || [[Roads and Fencing]] || 1 || 0 || 50 || 2L 1W || N/A
 |-
-| [[Fence Gate]]              || Roads and Fencing     || 1 || 0 || 40 || 15L 4W
+| [[Fence Gate]]              || Roads and Fencing     || 1 || 0 || 40 || 15L 4W || N/A
 |-
-| [[Fieldstone Fence]]        || Roads and Fencing     || 2 || <mark>?</mark> || <mark>?</mark> || 3L 1S
+| [[Fieldstone Fence]]        || Roads and Fencing     || 2 || 1 || 180 || 3L 1S || N/A
 |-
-| [[Hedge Fence]]             || Roads and Fencing     || 3 || <mark>?</mark> || <mark>?</mark> || 3L 4C 15G
+| [[Hedge Fence]]             || Roads and Fencing     || 3 || 0 || 100 || 3L 4C 15G || N/A
 |-
-| [[Hedge Fence Gate]]        || Roads and Fencing     || 3 || <mark>?</mark> || <mark>?</mark> || 50L 8W 15C 30G
+| [[Hedge Fence Gate]]        || Roads and Fencing     || 3 || 20<sup>2</sup> || 1800<sup>2</sup> || 50L 8W 15C 30G || N/A
 |-
-| [[Wrought Iron Fence]]      || Roads and Fencing     || 4 || <mark>?</mark> || <mark>?</mark> || 3L 3i 2C 15G
+| [[Wrought Iron Fence]]      || Roads and Fencing     || 4 || 2 || 200 || 3L 3i 2C 15G || N/A
 |-
-| [[Wrought Iron Fence Gate]] || Roads and Fencing     || 4 || <mark>?</mark> || <mark>?</mark> || 50L 10i 15C 50G
+| [[Wrought Iron Fence Gate]] || Roads and Fencing     || 4 || 20<sup>2</sup> || 1800<sup>2</sup> || 50L 10i 15C 50G || N/A
 |-
-| [[Palisade Wall]]           || [[Defenses]]          || 2 || <mark>?</mark> || <mark>?</mark> || 3L 3W
+| [[Palisade Wall]]           || [[Defenses]]          || 2 || 19 || 800 || 3L 3W || [[Fortified Wall]]
 |-
-| [[Palisade Gate]]           || Defenses              || 2 || <mark>?</mark> || <mark>?</mark> || 15L 12W
+| [[Palisade Gate]]           || Defenses              || 2 || 15 || 650 || 15L 12W || [[Fortified Gate]]
 |-
-| [[Fortified Wall]]          || Defenses              || 3 || 32 || 1500 || 10L 3S
+| [[Fortified Wall]]          || Defenses              || 3 || 32 || 1500 || 10L 3S || N/A
 |-
-| [[Fortified Gate]]          || Defenses              || 3 || 25 || 1200 || 50L 8W 10S
+| [[Fortified Gate]]          || Defenses              || 3 || 25 || 1200 || 50L 8W 10S || N/A
 |}
 <sup>1</sup> Cost in '''L'''abor, '''W'''ood, '''S'''tone, '''i'''ron, '''C'''lay, '''G'''old
+<br /><sup>2</sup> These numbers seem suspiciously out of line with all the others. [[Crate Entertainment]] has been notified.
+{{Note|The issue of the outrageous armor &amp; health values, for both the [[Hedge Fence Gate]] &amp; [[Wrought Iron Fence Gate]], was raised with [[Crate Entertainment]] as [https://forums.crateentertainment.com/t/hedge-fence-gate-and-wrought-iron-fence-gate-too-strong/130368 forum&nbsp;post&nbsp;#130368]. <small>(''2023-09-10'')</small>}}
+<mark>What is the '''labor cost''' to ''upgrade'' a palisade wall/gate to a fortified wall/gate?</mark>
+{{Warning|When ''upgrading'' a [[Palisade Wall]] to a [[Fortified Wall]] the game only indicates that it will cost 3 [[Stone]], and doesn't say anything about the labor cost.}}
+<mark>If you instead ''[[Salvage Building]]'', you ''will'' recover 2 [[Logs]] (which is the 50% of the original 3 logs investment ''rounded up'') and could then build the fortified wall in its place. Is the benefit of upgrading that the wall is still "there" ''during'' the upgrade process, not leaving you vulnerable?</mark>
+{{Warning|When ''upgrading'' a [[Palisade Gate]] to a [[Fortified Gate]] the game doesn't say anything about the labor cost, and  indicates that it will cost 8 [[Logs]] &amp; 10 [[Stone]] (even though you've already made a 12 log investment building the palisade gate).}}
+<mark>Similar with the palisade gate. Salvaging recovers 6 [[Logs]]. It is unknown if ''upgrading'' recovers any of the originally invested resources.</mark>
-<mark>What does it cost to ''upgrade'' a palisade wall to a fortified wall? Is there any discount?</mark>
-[[Category:Game Concepts]]
+[[Category:Combat]]